By Karabo Marifi
The Democratic Alliance (DA) has escalated its legal battle against the African National Congress (ANC)’s cadre deployment policy by petitioning the Supreme Court of Appeal (SCA). This move comes after the Gauteng High Court dismissed the DA’s application for leave to appeal an earlier ruling that upheld the policy’s constitutionality. The DA argues that the High Court’s decision sets a dangerous precedent, allowing party political influence to undermine the public service in violation of the Constitution.
As South Africa gears up for the 2026 elections, this ongoing fight could reshape the nation’s approach to governance and accountability.
The Legal Showdown: A Battle Over Cadre Deployment
The DA’s campaign against the ANC’s cadre deployment policy—a system where the ruling party appoints loyal supporters to key government and public sector roles—has reached a critical juncture. Earlier in 2025, the DA took its case to the Gauteng High Court in Pretoria, asking for the policy to be declared unconstitutional.
The court dismissed the application, ruling that cadre deployment does not breach the Constitution. The DA then sought permission to appeal this decision, but the High Court rejected that bid too, stating there were no grounds for a successful appeal.Now, the DA is turning to the SCA, arguing that the High Court’s judgment has “serious constitutional implications”. The party believes the ruling permits the ANC to keep placing party loyalists in public positions, which they say goes against the Constitution’s rules. Specifically, the DA points to Section 197, which says that no public servant should be given special treatment or unfairly treated just because they support a certain political party.
The DA wants the SCA to step in, grant the appeal, and issue an order declaring the ANC’s cadre deployment policy unlawful.“This is about more than just one policy—it’s about protecting the integrity of our public service,” said a DA spokesperson. “The High Court’s decision opens the door to political interference, and we can’t let that stand.
”What Is Cadre Deployment and Why Does It Matter?
Cadre deployment has been a key part of how the ANC runs the country since it took power in 1994. The policy is meant to ensure that people who share the party’s goals and values fill important roles in government departments and state-owned companies like Eskom or Transnet.
The ANC says this helps them carry out the promises they made to voters. But the DA and other critics see it differently—they argue that it’s a way for the ANC to reward loyalty instead of choosing the best people for the job.Over the years, this practice has been blamed for many of South Africa’s problems, like corruption, poor service delivery, and failing state institutions. For example, in some municipalities, unqualified party loyalists have been put in charge, leading to broken infrastructure and unpaid bills.
The DA says this shows how cadre deployment puts politics ahead of competence, hurting ordinary South Africans who rely on these services.The ANC, however, stands firm. “Cadre deployment is not about patronage; it’s about ensuring that the state machinery is aligned with the democratic mandate given to us by the voters,” said party spokesperson Pule Mabe. The ruling party insists that it’s a fair way to build a government that reflects the will of the people.
The Road to the Supreme Court: A Timeline of the Fight
The DA’s legal challenge didn’t start overnight—it’s been building for years. Back in 2022, the party got hold of internal ANC documents through a court order, revealing how the party’s deployment committee decides who gets top jobs.
These papers showed names of people recommended for positions in government and state entities, fuelling the DA’s claim that the ANC controls appointments behind closed doors.Fast forward to early 2025, and the DA launched its case in the Gauteng High Court. They argued that cadre deployment breaks the Constitution by letting party loyalty trump merit. The court disagreed, saying there wasn’t enough evidence to prove the policy itself was illegal. When the DA asked to appeal, the High Court doubled down, dismissing their request and leaving them with one option: take it higher.Now, with the SCA petition filed, the DA is hoping for a different outcome.
They’re asking the court to look at the bigger picture—how cadre deployment affects the whole public sector, not just a few appointments. If the SCA agrees to hear the case, it could be a game-changer. And if they win, it might even end up at the Constitutional Court for a final say
Real-Life Impact: Stories Behind the Policy
To understand why this fight matters, look at some of the cases tied to cadre deployment. Take Hlaudi Motsoeneng, who was made Chief Operating Officer of the SABC in 2014. He didn’t have a matric certificate or the right experience, yet he climbed the ranks, allegedly thanks to ANC backing.
His time at the SABC was a mess—financial losses piled up, and staff complained of chaos. Eventually, he was sacked, but the damage was done.Then there’s the story of Brian Molefe, appointed CEO of Eskom in 2015. While he had some qualifications, his close ties to the ANC raised eyebrows. Under his watch, Eskom got tangled in corruption scandals linked to state capture, leaving South Africans with endless power cuts.
These examples are why the DA says cadre deployment isn’t just a policy—it’s a problem that hits people’s lives every day.On the flip side, the ANC points to successes like the early days after 1994, when loyal cadres helped rebuild a civil service that had served apartheid. They argue that without this policy, the government might not have changed as fast as it did.What’s at Stake: Governance and the 2026 ElectionsThis legal battle isn’t happening in a vacuum—it’s tied to South Africa’s bigger struggles. Corruption, unemployment, and crumbling services have left many voters angry.
A 2024 survey found that 68% of South Africans think political appointments are a big reason for corruption in government. If the DA wins at the SCA, it could force the ANC to rethink how it picks people for jobs, maybe leading to better-run institutions. But if the ANC comes out on top, critics worry it’ll be business as usual, with loyalty trumping skill.With the 2026 national elections coming up, the timing couldn’t be more crucial.
The DA wants to use this fight to show voters they’re serious about fixing government.
“We’re standing up for a South Africa where jobs go to the best candidates, not the best-connected,” said DA leader John Steenhuisen. Meanwhile, the ANC will have to convince people that cadre deployment isn’t the root of the country’s woes—a tough sell when lights go out and taps run dry.The Government of National Unity (GNU), set up after the 2024 elections, adds another layer.
The ANC and DA are partners in this shaky coalition, but clashes like this could strain it further. Some worry that if these fights keep happening, the GNU might not hold together long enough to tackle South Africa’s challenges.
Voices Weigh In: Experts and Everyday
People analysts are split on what might happen next. Political expert Ralph Mathekga says the issue isn’t black-and-white: “Cadre deployment can work if there’s transparency and accountability. The real problem is when it’s abused.” Others think the DA has a tough road ahead.
Legal scholar Pierre de Vos argues that the courts might not see the policy itself as illegal, but rather how it’s carried out in practice.Ordinary South Africans are chiming in too. On social media, one user posted, “The DA is fighting for all South Africans by challenging cadre deployment—it’s about saving our institutions.” Another hit back: “This is just politics. The ANC won’t stop doing what’s kept them in power for 30 years.”
The debate’s heating up, and it’s clear people care about what’s at stake.New Angles: Beyond the CourtroomThere’s more to this story than legal arguments. Recently, whistleblowers from within the ANC have claimed that cadre deployment isn’t just about loyalty—it’s also a way to control money and power. They say some party insiders use it to place allies in jobs where they can steer contracts to friends or family.
While these claims haven’t been proven in court, they add fuel to the DA’s fire.On the global stage, South Africa’s governance woes are getting noticed. Reports from groups like the World Bank have warned that political appointments could scare off investors who want a stable, well-run country. If the SCA rules against cadre deployment, it might send a signal that South Africa is serious about cleaning up its act.
🔴 Central News Special Edition | Issue 104 🔴 Download the Latest Print and E-Edition | Headline: DA’s Helen Zille Accuses ANC of Using Employment Equity Law to “Shrink Jobs and Punish Business”
Download Here:
Direct PDF Link:
https://centralnews.co.za/wp-content/uploads/2025/05/Central-News-Issue-104.pdf
Read all our publications on magzter:
https://www.magzter.com/ZA/Central-News-Pty-Ltd/Central-News/Newspaper/All-Issues
Central News also offers Sponsored Editorial Content, Podcasts , Radio / Social Media Simulcast, Video Production , Live Streaming Services, Press Conferences, and Paid Interviews (Video/Audio) etc.
We guarantee exceptional exposure, reach, and engagement, with an excellent return on investment.
Advertisement:
To place your advert on our platforms (Print Newspaper or Digital Platforms) : Please email : sales@centralnews.co.za
For Business Related:
business@centralnews.co.za
Newsroom:
Send your Stories / Media Statements To: newsroom@centralnews.co.za
General Info:
info@centralnews.co.za
Office Administrator:
admin@centralnews.co.za
Whatsapp / Call: 081 495 5487
Website: https://www.centralnews.co.za
Social Media Platforms (@centralnewsza) : Linkedin, Facebook, Tiktok, Twitter, Instagram, Youtube