Basic Education Minister
By Lerato Mpembe
Boksburg – Basic Education Minister Siviwe Gwarube has defended the department’s partnership with global fast-food franchise McDonald’s, standing firm amid a storm of criticism this week. The collaboration sparked outrage after social media posts showed brightly coloured yellow and red McDonald’s-branded desks, designed to fold into bags that learners can carry home. Speaking on the sidelines of the 10th annual Basic Education Lekgotla at Birchwood Hotel in Boksburg on Thursday, 27 February 2025, Gwarube said the decision was carefully thought out and aimed at tackling the department’s deep-rooted challenges.
A Controversial Partnership Takes Centre Stage
South Africa’s education system is no stranger to tough times, with crumbling infrastructure and tight budgets making headlines for years. But this week, a new debate erupted when the Department of Basic Education (DBE) teamed up with McDonald’s South Africa to roll out portable desks for learners. Photos splashed across X and Facebook showed kids in the Eastern Cape and Western Cape hauling foldable desks – complete with the iconic golden arches logo – to and from school. The backlash was swift, with many calling it a gimmick or a corporate branding stunt.
Minister Gwarube, however, isn’t backing down. “Gwarube has dug in her heels and said the decision was not taken on a whim,” a DBE spokesperson confirmed on Wednesday. Addressing reporters at the Lekgotla, she explained why the partnership matters. “With the financial and infrastructure challenges faced by the department, Gwarube said the collaboration was welcomed,” noted a statement from her office. For her, it’s about giving kids a fighting chance to learn, no matter where they live.
The Lekgotla, themed “Strengthening Foundations for Learning for a Resilient Future Fit Education System,” kicked off this week with President Cyril Ramaphosa delivering the keynote address. It’s the 10th year of this gathering, where education leaders, teachers, and stakeholders hash out solutions to the sector’s woes. And on day one, budget constraints were front and centre – a perfect backdrop for Gwarube’s defence of the McDonald’s deal.
Why McDonald’s? The Minister Explains
The portable desks – developed by MiDesk Global and sponsored partly by McDonald’s – aren’t just any furniture. They’re lightweight, weighing only 2 kilograms, and double as a wheelie schoolbag that unfolds into a desk and chair. Some even come with a solar light and USB charging port, a nod to homes without electricity. Gwarube highlighted their approval by UNESCO, a global education body, as a key factor in the decision.
“Firstly, these desks have been approved by UNESCO, they are 2 kilograms heavy and UNESCO has indicated that these are absolutely appropriate but what is important for me is that there are children in this country who go to places and homes where they don’t have even an area to do their homework,” she said at the Lekgotla. For Gwarube, it’s personal – she’s seen too many learners struggle without basic tools to study.
South Africa’s education crisis is stark. A 2024 World Bank report flagged that three million kids lack desks in schools, especially in rural areas like the Eastern Cape and Limpopo. At home, it’s worse – many don’t have a table or quiet space to crack open their books. Gwarube sees the McDonald’s desks as a small but smart fix. “The department felt the initiative was innovative, giving less fortunate children some help to continue learning at home,” she told reporters.
The Backlash: Fair or Overblown?
Not everyone’s cheering. Social media lit up with criticism after the desks debuted on Monday, 24 February 2025, at St Paul’s Primary School in Bo-Kaap, Cape Town. Gwarube handed them out herself, calling them a “brilliant solution” on X via @Siviwe_G. But posts on X quickly turned sour. One user wrote, “McDonald’s desks are a gimmick that won’t improve a thing. Is corporate advertising in schools even allowed?” Another fumed, “This is just fancy advertising for McDonald’s – kids shouldn’t be billboards.”
The branding – bold yellow and red with the McDonald’s logo – rubbed many the wrong way. Critics argue it’s unfair to burden poorer learners with carrying desks while wealthier kids enjoy fixed furniture. “A few social media users also pointed out how carrying a desk imposed extra effort on poorer learners as opposed to those from more affluent backgrounds,” noted an IOL report on 26 February. Some even questioned the health angle, with X posts claiming fast-food branding promotes obesity in a country already battling diabetes.
But Gwarube’s team pushed back. “This isn’t about advertising – it’s about solutions,” a DBE official told SABC News on 26 February. McDonald’s chipped in too, saying they’ve donated over one million books to SA schools since 2023, alongside desks. “We’re here to help, not sell burgers,” a spokesperson told TimesLIVE on 25 February.
Budget Blues Fuel the Debate
Day one of the Lekgotla laid bare the DBE’s money troubles. Gwarube told delegates that a shrinking budget threatens thousands of teacher posts in 2025. “Budget constraints feature strongly on day one of Basic Education Lekgotla,” read an SABC News headline on 26 February. With pit toilets still plaguing schools – despite a March 2025 deadline to erase them – and classrooms falling apart, every rand counts.
That’s where partnerships like McDonald’s come in. Alongside Old Mutual, the fast-food giant funded the MiDesk rollout in the Eastern Cape and Western Cape, targeting underprivileged Grade 1 learners. “When you’ve got no cash, you get creative,” said education analyst Dr Peter Jacobs in a CapeTalk interview on 26 February. “This isn’t ideal, but it’s something.”
The DBE’s been here before. In 2023, Shoprite donated desks to KwaZulu-Natal schools, and no one blinked. So why the uproar now? “It’s the branding,” Jacobs suggested. “People see McDonald’s and think junk food, not help.” Gwarube, though, sees it differently – for her, it’s a lifeline for kids who’d otherwise study on the floor.
A Closer Look at the Desks
The MiDesk isn’t new – it’s been in the works for 18 months, long before Gwarube took office in mid-2024. Designed by MiDesk Global, it’s a foldable marvel: a bag one minute, a desk the next. At 2 kilograms, it’s light enough for a Grade 1 learner to lug around, and the solar light tackles a real problem – nearly 20% of rural SA homes lack power, per Stats SA’s 2023 General Household Survey.
UNESCO’s stamp of approval matters too. Their guidelines say school gear must be safe, practical, and age-appropriate, and the MiDesk ticks those boxes. “These aren’t just desks – they’re tools for learning,” Gwarube said at the Lekgotla. She’s not wrong – a 2024 DBE survey found 60% of rural learners struggle with homework due to no study space.
Critics still scoff. “Too cumbersome for kids,” tweeted @mark_wuger on 25 February. GOOD Party MP Brett Herron called it “absolutely bizarre” on X, arguing taxpayers deserve proper school furniture. Gwarube fired back: “We’re not replacing desks – we’re adding options where there are none.”
Voices from the Ground
What do parents and teachers think? In Bo-Kaap, St Paul’s principal Amina Desai told Cape Argus on 25 February that the desks are a hit. “Our kids love them – they’re excited to take them home,” she said. One parent, Nomsa Mkhize from the Eastern Cape, agreed in an EWN interview: “My girl’s got no table at home. This helps.”
But not everyone’s sold. In Qumbu, Eastern Cape, teacher Sipho Ndlovu told African Insider on 26 February that the desks feel like a Band-Aid. “We need real classrooms, not portable fixes,” he said. Posts on X echo this – one user wrote, “Why are we paying taxes if kids carry their own desks?”
Kids have a say too. Ten-year-old Lindiwe from Bo-Kaap grinned at SowetanLIVE cameras on 24 February, saying, “It’s cool – I can do my sums anywhere now.” But her classmate Thabo grumbled, “It’s heavy after a while.”
Education in Crisis: The Bigger Picture
The McDonald’s saga is just one piece of South Africa’s education puzzle. At the Lekgotla, Gwarube told delegates the sector’s in “crisis,” a point she’s made since her State of the Nation Address (SONA) debate on 12 February. A World Bank report this month warned that poor early learning sets SA kids up to fail – only 37% of Grade 4 learners can read for meaning, per the 2021 PIRLS study.
Ramaphosa, speaking at the Lekgotla on 27 February, backed Gwarube’s push for partnerships. “We can’t do this alone,” he said, per SowetanLIVE. He touted “smart education” – tech and innovation – as the future, nodding to tools like the MiDesk. But with 548 bullying cases since January and pit toilets lingering, per TimesLIVE on 26 February, the to-do list is long.
Gwarube’s no stranger to heat. She’s clashed with her own Democratic Alliance (DA) party over the 2024 matric pass rate – they called it 53.6%, she stuck to 87.3% – and brushed off Gauteng Premier Panyaza Lesufi’s single-exam idea in January. Now, she’s fighting for every cent from Finance Minister Enoch Godongwana to save jobs and desks.
🔴 Central News Special Edition | Issue 94 🔴 Download the Latest Print and E-Edition | Headline: “I am a proud International criminal,
Malema Fires back at Musk and Trump”
Download Here:
Direct PDF Link:
https://centralnews.co.za/wp-content/uploads/2025/02/Central-News-Issue-094.pdf
Read all our publications on magzter:
https://www.magzter.com/ZA/Central-News-Pty-Ltd/Central-News/Newspaper/All-Issues
Central News also offers Sponsored Editorial Content, Podcasts , Radio / Social Media Simulcast, Video Production , Live Streaming Services, Press Conferences, and Paid Interviews (Video/Audio) etc.
We guarantee exceptional exposure, reach, and engagement, with an excellent return on investment.
Advertisement:
To place your advert on our platforms (Print Newspaper or Digital Platforms) : Please email : sales@centralnews.co.za
For Business Related:
business@centralnews.co.za
Newsroom:
Send your Stories / Media Statements To: newsroom@centralnews.co.za
General Info:
info@centralnews.co.za
Office Administrator:
admin@centralnews.co.za
Whatsapp / Call: 081 495 5487
Website: https://www.centralnews.co.za
Social Media Platforms (@centralnewsza) : Linkedin, Facebook, Tiktok, Twitter, Instagram, Youtube